After the establishment of Migros, Gima was established as a national supermarket
chain and aimed to supply main food products cheaper as Migros. During these years, private
companies have not been developed yet and government was still the dominant factor in the
economy. Retail sector did not require high capital, qualified employees, and entry barriers
(Erdogan, 2003).
In 1960s, private companies such as Beymen, Vakko, Yeni Karamürsel, and IGS
began to rise in the retail sector whereas the biggest retail companies were just consumption
cooperatives which developed self-service retailing concept in these years (Bocutoglu and
Atasoy, 2001). These activities that contribute to the development of retailing sector initiate
the establishment of multi-storey stores and chain stores (Savasci, 2002).
Tansas which was established in 1973 with the goal of providing cheaper meat and
coal opened its first store in 1976 in Izmir and improved the supermarket technology in the
retail industry. The numbers of food retailers have begun to rise in the industry. Food
retailing aims to satisfy consumer needs by offering food and non-food products, and also
customer services (Ozkan and Akpinar, 2003). Within the scope of these developments at the
end of 70s, there were two main alterations in the sector: food retailers started to offer nonfood
products such as detergent and oil besides the food products, and traditional mom-andpop
store retailers began to specialize on one product line especially food products instead of
specializing on perfumery products, stationery products, and drugs (Erdogan, 2003). The
draft law on encouragement of large scale retailers in 1973 was suggested to improve retail
industry however; it has failed (Tek and Ozgul, 2005).
The Period after 1980: Privatization and Internationalization
Until 1980s import-substituting policies have been followed in Turkish economy. In
the year 1980, these policies were left and the policies related to open to foreign countries
with export-led began to be followed. Export activities were encouraged by applications such
as subsidies and tax refund, and domestic commodity markets were opened to the
world markets. In 1989, with the removal of all the arrangements concerning international
capital movements, the convertibility of the national currency was ensured and the economy
was opened to foreign countries completely (Kose and Oncu, 2000). Government policies
oriented towards deregulation in retailing as well as in the economy generally. Privatisation
was one of the major policies of government to liberalise the economy. Migros was privatised
in 1975 by Koc Holding, and also Gima was privatised soon after government announced its
privatisation plans. To encourage foreign and big domestic investments, the government gave
incentives to the retailers. The establishment of shopping centres and large stores, also called
big box retailers, were supported through investment incentives starting in 1985 (Ozcan,
2001). The first shopping centre called Galeria was opened in Istanbul in 1988. The retail
industry has gone through major changes since the late 80s.
Coskun (2001) claimed that Turkey's stance on foreign investment has become
increasingly open and aggressive since the major economic policy shift from importsubstituting
towards export-led development in 1980. International investors have been
taking an increasingly part in the Turkish economy. Reshaped foreign investment regime
makes it possible that all fields open to the Turkish private sector are open to foreign
investment without any limitation. Consequently, total foreign investment reached from $97
million in 1980 to over $8.6 billion in 1998. Foreign investments have been still going on to
increase and new laws have been developed. The Encouragement of Foreign Investment Law
- No. 6224 in 1954 was enhanced, updated, and turned into the Foreign Direct Investment
Law - No. 4875 in 2003 (Ozbilgic, 2012).
Turkish retail structure was fragmented and non-integrated until 1990s; small-scale,
capital-weak, independent, and family owned retailers were dominating the retail trade
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
116
(Kumcu and Kumcu, 1987; Samli, 1964, 1970; Kaynak, 1982, 1986; Tokatli and Boyaci,
1998). The years 1990s were the beginning of retail era for Turkey, 2000s were the years of
modern retailing and internationalisation movements (Tek and Ozgul, 2005). In 1992, the
numbers of grocery stores were 124.877 whereas the numbers of supermarkets were 11.373
(Kursunluoglu, 2006). Organized food retailing was developing slowly in these years. During
90s, many retailers have started to operate in Turkey and during 2000s internationalisation
movements strengthened the industry. The Germany’s largest cash and carry store Metro
entered into Turkish market in 1990. Promodes that was founded in 1961 in France as a
supermarket opened its operations in Turkey. Another French hypermarket Carrefour began
to operate in Turkey in 1993. In 1996, it became CarrefourSA after the joint venture
association between Carrefour and Sabanci Holding. Kipa was established in Izmir with the
investments of 100 investors in 1992 and opened its first store in 1994 in Izmir. Bim that
became the number one in Q Ratio among 250 retailers according to the Deloitte (2013)
opened its first store in 1995 as a discount retailer.
Tokatli and Boyaci (1998) showed the foreign retailers in the industry: US companies
McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken and Pizza Hut entered into the market in the late 1980s,
Subway and Burger King in the 1990s. French Printemps (1987) and British Marks and
Spencer (1995) were among the pioneering retailers in the department or variety store
category. In the clothing sector many retailers entered into the Turkish market for example
Italy’s Benetton (1986) and Sisley (1991), the US company Levi’s (1989), the British retailer
Mothercare (1988), and many others such as Burberry’s, Austin Reed, Stefanel, Versace,
Ermenegildo Zegna, Naf Naf, and Chanel.
It was also possible to see different retail format in these years with the increasing
capacity of foreign investments. Direct selling is a type of non-store retailing and category
killer retailers are the types of store retailing (Varinli and Oyman, 2013; Kursunluoglu,
2009). Direct selling has been improved in Turkey in 1990s; the US companies Avon and
Amway started their operations in 1993. The US company Toys R Us and the Swedish Ikea
entered into the Turkish market in 1996 and 2003 respectively as category killers.
Along with the new retailers' operations in the industry, the retail industry has
developed. Modern retailing has been improved and has replaced of traditional retailing
activities. Yilmaz and Altunisik (2003) showed that the biggest national groups started to
invest in Turkish retail sector and Turkey became a country that has been given priority for
entering by the foreign investors. The retail sector has continued to grow up as the numbers
of national and international retailers increase.
At the beginning of 2000s, Turkish economy has suffered from the financial crises
and before the end of the effects of 2000 crisis, 2001 crisis has arisen (Yeldan, 2001). It was
shown that after these crises, most sectors preferred downsizing however; organized retailing
sector especially supermarkets continued to grow. In 2005, the numbers of organized retailers
have increased but the numbers of grocery stores were still higher than the numbers of
organized retailers. The numbers of supermarkets were 968 in 2003; it increased to 1.258 in
2005 (Kursunluoglu, 2006). The profits of organized retailers began to increase thanks to
lower price, and higher sales promotions against traditional retailers such as grocery,
stationery, and perfumery stores. The competition in the retailing sector has still been in
progress not only among organized retailers but also organized and traditional retailers.
Turkey Grocery Stores and Dealers Federation (2000) showed that market shares of
hypermarkets and supermarkets in the total retail market were 10 % in 1995, 14 % in 1997
and it was estimated that it would reach 35 % in 2004. Consumers preferred purchasing from
organized retailers instead of grocery stores due to supermarkets offered lots of products
varieties, faster service, store atmosphere elements such as exhibition and internal design,
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
117
wide shopping area, reliable image, lower price, early opening and late closing, different
customer services such as parking, café, restaurant, and playground.
Towards the end of 2000s, Turkish retail industry has evolved with domestic and
foreign investments. 2000s were the years of modernization work and internationalization. In
the year 2003, English supermarket chain Tesco acquired Kipa and moved on the operations
as Tesco Kipa. In 2005, Carrefour acquired Gima and Endi which belong to Fiba Holding.
American discount store chain Wal-Mart has thought to enter Turkish market through
acquiring Migros. Migros opened its first outside store in 1996 in Baku, Azerbaijan under the
name of Ramstore. Except these internationalization activities, mergers and acquisitions have
continued among Turkish retailers. For example, Migros acquired Tansas in 2005. Thus,
Migros became the biggest food retailer with 721 stores in Turkey.
Ozcan (2007) analysed Migros activities and according to Ozcan, Migros made a
strategic decision to expand in Russia and central Asia since it was nearly impossible to enter
the European market for an emerging Turkish retailer while European competitors such as
Tesco focused on the Eastern European market. Migros have become a symbol of modern
retailing in Russia and central Asia. In 2006, Migros had three stores in Azerbaijan, ten
shopping malls and forty-nine stores in Russia and two shopping malls and five stores in
Kazakhstan; it also had stores in Bulgaria and one store and a hypermarket in Macedonia.
Baku was selected as a first case of international expansion because of its cultural and
physically closest to Turkey. It was followed by the investments in Russia, Kazakhstan, and,
Balkans (Bulgaria and Macedonia) and these investments made Migros international retailer.
Migros entered the Russian market during the economic crisis in 1998 as Ramstore.
Ramstores were welcomed by Russian politicians and consumers at a time when Russia was
not an attractive market for large Western retailers and there were still food shortages.
Turkey Grocery Stores and Dealers Federation (2000) claimed that consumers
preferred hypermarkets and supermarkets instead of grocery stores because of they offered
low price. Kursunluoglu (2008) showed that consumers preferred hypermarkets and
supermarkets instead of grocery stores thereby some reasons except price such as being a
reliable retailer, having broad merchandise assortments, and having an impressive in-store
atmosphere.
The law drafts about protecting the competition in retail industry have been prepared
for many years. The first law was prepared in 1973 as it was mentioned below, and the
second one was prepared in 2008 to protect small sized retailers. According to the law draft,
supermarkets and hypermarkets over than 400 m² should establish out of town, have free car
park and limited working hours. There are many laws in other countries such as Sherman
Antitrust Act of 1890, Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914, Robinson–Patman Act of 1936 in
America, Sapin Law in 1993 in France, PPG6 in 1988 in England (Lebhar, 2012; Courser,
2005; OECD, 1998; Tek, 2008; Wood et al., 2006). The urban population is higher in Turkey
than other European countries. It has been creating the potential use of both shopping centres
and traditional retailers. Yet small-scale retailing has been struggling to compete with
organized, large scale retailers and shopping centres, it seems that the competition has
continued to favour the latter (Erkip et al., 2013).
Characteristics of Turkish Retailing
Ozcan (1997) showed the five main elements that influence and form the Turkish
retailing sector. The first element was the evolution of specialization in Turkish retailing.
Within this evolution, store concept and its product line have changed from the stores that sell
everything to the stores that specialize on specific product line. The second element was the
opening domestic market to the foreign countries thanks to economic growth and liberal
politics. It has increased the capacity of foreign investments in retail sector. New
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
118
technologies and technics were the third element that affect retail sector in a positive way,
thus retail sector has begun to be more organized and modern retailing has developed. The
fourth element was that multinational European retailers’ interests on Southern European
markets have influenced Turkish retail sector. Mergers and acquisitions have provided to
enter the advanced methods into the retail industry. The fifth element was the increasing in
disposable income and formation of new consumption models. For example, consumer
behaviours have changed and consumers have begun to develop different shopping styles
such as buying from shopping centres since shopping centres contain every need in
specialized stores under one roof.
Retailing sector has been developing for two decades in Turkey. Especially after the
year 2000, the industry became the pioneer sector of the economy since its increasing
attraction. The attraction of retail sector have been affected by some factors (Cengiz and
Ozden, 2002; Tahiroglu, 1999) such as increasing in consumption, increasing the numbers of
large sized retailers’ stores, attracting investments through deferred payment and cash selling,
being profitable investments in the long term for the investors since finding the appropriate
location for stores were limited and expensive, increasing the encouragements of foreign
investors by domestic investors about entry strategies like mergers, acquisitions, joint
ventures.
There were two main factors that European retail chains entered Turkish market. The
first one was that per capita consumption rates had reached a stable structure in Western
Europe. The second reason was about the restriction of hypermarkets’ activities for
conserving the competition in the industry. The most important countries in trans-boundary
retailing were England, France, and Germany (Erdogan, 2003).
Turkish retailing shares many of the characteristics of other Southern European
economies such as the presence of a large number of small and individually operated
companies, a modest rate of capital accumulation, and traditional food production and
distribution systems which are also typical in Greece, Portugal, and Spain (Ozcan, 2000;
Bennison, 1995; Salgueiro, 1995) and also Eastern European countries such as Hungary and
Poland where the transformation of retailing has also been recognized as incipient in 1990s
(Tokatli and Boyaci, 1998).
Table 1: The most common retail formats in Europe
Channel 1 Channel 2 Channel 3
France Hypermarket Supermarket Specialty Stores
England Superstore Supermarket Convenience Stores
Germany Discount Stores Hypermarket Specialty Stores
Italy Supermarket Hypermarket Specialty Stores
Spain Hypermarket Supermarket Specialty Stores
Source: Myers, 2003, Orel, 2010.
Myers (2003) showed the most common retail formats in Europe and they were
generally food retailers as it can be seen in Table 1. UK food retailers have not been as
ambitious as their counterparts in the non-food retail sector; they have been more concerned
with the development of the superstore format in the domestic market (Myers and Alexander,
1996). Turkish retailing also has focused on the food retailing in these years. Torlak et al.
(2005) shows that the customers of supermarkets and discount stores have different
behaviours; for example the supermarket customers perceive physical aspects and store
policy dimensions at a higher level whereas the discount store customers give more priority
to the interaction with personnel dimension.
Table 2 below shows the top ten retailers worldwide in 2011. Wal-Mart was number
one in annual revenue with $ 446,950 million and its growth share was just 6 % whereas
Costco’s revenue growth was the highest with 14.1 %.
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
119
Table 2: Top 10 Retailers Worldwide, 2011
Rank Name
Country of
origin
Retail
revenue
(US$mil)
Retail
revenue
growth
Numbers of
countries
in operation
% revenue from
foreign
operations
1 Wal-Mart U.S. 446,950 6.0 % 28 28.4 %
2 Carrefour France 113,197 - 9.8 % 33 56.7 %
3 Tesco U.K. 101,574 5.8 % 13 34.5 %
4 Metro Germany 92,905 - 0.8 % 33 61.1 %
5 Kroger U.S. 90,374 10.0 % 1 0.0 %
6 Costco U.S. 88,915 14.1 % 9 27.0 %
7 Schwarz Germany 87,841 5.8 % 26 55.8 %
8 Aldi Germany 73,375 3.7 % 17 57.1 %
9 Walgreen U.S. 72,184 7.1 % 2 1.5 %
10 The Home Depot U.S. 70,395 3.5 % 5 11.4 %
Source: Deloitte, 2013
Carrefour and Metro had the biggest share in the numbers of countries served and they
took more than half of their revenues through foreign operations. Also German retailers Aldi
and Schwarz took the biggest part of their revenues through their foreign operations however
their foreign operations were less than Carrefour and Metro.
According to Deliotte (2013); fast moving consumer good (FMCG) sector was the
leading sector in 2011. The share of retail companies by sector: 54 % FMCG (135 companies
of 250), 22 % hardlines and leisure (55 companies of 250), 15.6 % fashion (39 companies of
250), 8.4 % diversified (21 companies of 250). The retail market for FMCG consists of
various retail channels. The International Standard Industry Classification (ISIC, Revision 3)
classifies retail channels into seven categories at the 4-digit level: ISIC 5211 retail sale in
non-specialized stores, ISIC 5219 other retail sale in non-specialized stores (department
stores, etc), ISIC 5220 retail sale of food, beverages and tobacco in specialized stores, ISIC
5231 retail sale of pharmaceutical and medical goods, cosmetic and toilet articles, ISIC 5251
retail sale via mail order houses, ISIC 5252 retail sale via stalls and markets, and ISIC 5259
other non-store retail sale. There is no firm in categories ISIC 5251 and 5252 in Turkey
(Celen et al., 2005). Within the effects of globalization, Turkish retailing concentrate on
FMCG sector with its numerous retailers. The growth rate of FMCG in Turkey was 0.8 % in
November 2011 whereas it increased to 4.8 % in September 2013 (Retail Turkiye, 2013).
Relations with Albania
The Turkish retail industry has been developing since 1980s. It has too many foreign
operations and Turkish retailers have begun to enter foreign countries for a long time.
Turkish foreign operations in Albania were analysed since retailing sector in Albania takes
too much investments nowadays and one of the strongest investors in Albanian retail industry
is Turkey.
Albania was classified as low-medium country in terms of degree of privatization and
development of retail sector according to the information about foreign direct investment,
governmental efforts, retail sales level, number and type of retailers. Albania seemed to have
limited development in the retailing sector, and thus was rated as a low-medium country. In
the result of cluster analysis, it was classified as Low to Low–Medium (LLM) developed
country (Manrai et al, 2001). Bitzenis and Nito (2005) analyzed the obstacles and problems
encountered when doing business in Albania and showed that the most important obstacles
were unfair competition, changes in taxation procedures, lack of financial resources, and
problems related to public order.
In recent years the transitioning economy, the new class of consumers, and the change
in the food retail sector have changed consumer behaviour and consumption preferences in
Albania (Chan-Halbrendt et al., 2010). Albanian consumer behaviours and life styles have
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
120
changed because of the economic growth, improvement in the standard of living, fast
urbanization, and trade liberalization in the country. The transition from a centrally planned
socialist economy to a market oriented economy has also given rise to a larger urban middleincome
class of consumers. The food demand from the emerging urban middle-income
consumers, combined with the gradual consolidation of the retail sector and the recent
establishment of the first supermarket chains, has strong implications for the agrifood
industry, which in the past has been almost exclusively based on price (Leonetti et al. 2009).
Increase in urban middle income consumers along with consolidation of the retail sector has
created changes in consumption preferences in Albania.
The GRDI ranks the top 30 developing countries on a 0-to-100-point scale for retail
investment based on several macroeconomic and retail-specific variables such as market
attractiveness (25%), country risk (25%), market saturation (25%), and time pressure (25%).
The countries were classified as “on the radar”-first ten countries, “to consider”- countries in
the rank 11-20, and “lower priority”- countries in the rank 21-30. Some countries from the
2013 GRDI were shown in Table 3.
Table 3: 2013 Global Retail Development Index™
Rank 2013 Country MA* CR* MS* TP* GRDI Rank 2012
1 Brazil 100 86.2 43.3 48.3 69.5 -
2 Chile 95.6 100 18.7 54.3 67.1 -
3 Uruguay 92 73.9 63.5 36.5 66.5 +1
4 China 62.1 67.9 34.3 100 66.1 -1
5 United Arab
Emirates
95.8 94.6 3 60.8 63.5 +2
6 Turkey 86.8 83.7 28.9 50.9 62.6 +7
7 Mongolia 17.7 37 99 96.5 62.5 +2
8 Georgia 36.6 63.8 83.4 61.9 61.4 -2
9 Kuwait 87.8 87.1 36.4 22.2 58.4 +3
10 Armenia 32.3 63.6 93.5 43.6 58.2 N/A
15 Sri Lanka 16.6 60.5 81.8 58.6 54.4 -
20 Jordan 53.1 65 65.9 19.6 50.9 -2
25 Botswana 38.7 82 31.8 38.5 47.8 -5
30 Albania 30.6 35 73.6 40.9 45.1 -5
* MA = Market attractiveness. 0 = low attractiveness, 100 = high attractiveness; CR = Country risk. 0 = high
risk, 100 = low risk; MS = Market saturation. 0 = saturated, 100 = not saturated; TP = Time pressure. 0 = no
time pressure, 100 = urgency to enter
Source: A.T. Kearney, 2013
Turkey continues to grow up and it moves seven spots in the GRDI to take 6th place.
In Turkey, retail expansion is fuelled by strong consumer demand and high levels of
disposable income. The modern retail environment is becoming more diverse in this market,
with sectors such as luxury, apparel, and consumer electronics booming and quickly
expanding outside of major cities. Albania at 30th rank remains attractive to some
international retailers, particularly from neighbouring markets, yet their potential has fallen
compared to other developing markets in the GRDI because of their small size and low levels
of consumer wealth. Although the economic situation in Greece and Italy has affected
consumer spending in Albania, government moves to liberalize the economic framework.
Belgian food retailer Delhaize has emerged as a leader in the market after its 2011 acquisition
of Delta M Group, with 19 outlets in the country. Carrefour's Marinopoulos franchise
acquired the Euromax supermarket chain to strengthen its position in Albania. The market
has plenty of room for growth. With small, independent stores dominating the landscape, the
top five grocery players represent only 2 percent of the market (A.T. Kearney, 2013).
Kaleshi and Solanki (2010) showed that the EU countries made 77% of all companies
operating in Albania, with a total number of 1,000 foreign companies. Italy and Greece are
the main investors due to the fact that these countries are bordering Albania. Moreover, these
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
121
two countries are the main export countries of Albanian products. When taking into
consideration the numbers of foreign companies operating in Albania, 40% of foreign
companies were Italian, while 26% of them are Greek. During the years 1998-2007, Albanian
Government has signed mainly trade agreements with some countries to stimulate FDI
inflows, and one of them was Turkey. The Balkan countries made 13% of the total number of
the investing companies, and they were dominated by Turkey, which made 8% of the total
number of foreign companies operating in Albania.
Free Trade Agreement between Turkey and Albania was signed in 2006. With this
agreement, tariff and non-tariff barriers were eliminated and numerous subjects such as
sanitary and phytosanitary measures, technical barriers to trade, intellectual property, rules of
origin, internal taxation, anti-dumping and countervailing measures, safeguards, and balance
of payments measures were regulated. Trade volume between Turkey and Albania was
estimated as 354 million US$ in 2012 with a contraction of 10 % compared to 2011. In 2012,
imports from Albania were 99 million US$, whereas exports to Albania were 256 million
US$ (Ministry of Economy, 2012).
According to the foreign capital stock of Albania (Kaleshi and Solanki, 2010); the
main investor was Greece with 54 % of the total investments. The Greek investments in
Albania were spread up in the following sectors: 62 % in the telecommunication,
transportation and depot sector; 18 % in the banking sector; 7 % in the industry sector.
Turkey was the second investors 12 % of the investments. There has been a privatization of
important sectors in the Albanian economy, including land lines of telecommunication
through the company ALB Telekom, and this has made Turkey the second country. Italian
companies were the third with 11 % of the capital inflows in Albania. Two main sectors were
banking and industry sector. The fourth country was Austria with 10 % of the investment in
two main sectors as banking and insurance. Germany (3 %), USA (2%) were the other
investor countries.
According to Kaleshi and Solanki (2010), foreign enterprises have operated in
different sectors in Albania. The first sector was trade/retail shops and trade arbitrage, the
second sector was industry, mainly textiles and clothing by Italian companies, and the third
was banking sector. On the other hand, the main sector of investment is the transportation,
storage, and communication sector. This sector represents 40.5 % of the capital. The second
sector was monetary and financial intermediaries with 33 % of total capital, the third sector
was processing industry with 11 % of capital and the fourth sector was wholesale and retail
trade, automobiles, motorcycles, personal belongings and appliances with 5.9 % of total
capital.
The biggest Turkish investor in Albania is Calik Holding. It was one of the main
players of the communication sector of Albania by acquiring the largest fixed line and
internet provider (Albtelecom) and its GSM license (Eagle Mobile) in 2007. Eagle Mobile
was the first operator that offers edge and mobile TV. Mukli et al. (2012) analysed the FDI
and entry strategies of foreign mobile operators to Albania market. In this context, Vodafone
Albania and Eagle Mobile have been analysed as the biggest operators in Albania.
Albtelecom has increased its market efficiency by offering high service quality, powerful
technical infrastructure, and special campaigns. Calik Holding acquired 60 percent shares of
Banka Kombetare Tregtare (BKT), the second biggest bank of Albania. BKT which was
selected the best bank of Albania twice aimed to develop its position in Albanian economy
(Calik, 2009).
Mucaj (2013) claimed that Albania is a tax heaven and there is no custom duty for all
capital investment from investment companies. In the last 20 years, Turkey has invested
approximately US$1 billion in Albania. Turkey and Albania have over 160 bilateral
agreements in almost every area of cooperation. More than Turkey's 50 largest companies
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
122
operate currently in the Albania. Total trade volume between two countries reached 43.840
million leke in 2012. Albania import textile products from Turkey (KobiEfor, 2013). There
are lots of Turkish brands such as Koton, Lc Waikiki, Little Big, and Collezione in Albanian
shopping centres such as QTU and City Park. Pegasus Airlines has continued its investments
in Albania as a service retailer.
Conclusion
In a conclusion, there has been lots of trade capacity between two countries especially
in retail industry. Two countries have lots of common share in economic perspective. Small
and medium sized enterprises have significant role in both economies (Keskin and Senturk,
2010). The investments in retail industry should be developed by the governments’
incentives. The future research may focus on analysing the incentives and barriers of Turkish
investments in Albania with the technics of survey.
References:
A.T. Kearney, (2013), The 2013 Global Retail Development Index™,
https://www.atkearney.com/consumer-products-retail/global-retail-development-index/fullreport/-/asset_publisher/oPFrGkbIkz0Q/content/2013-global-retail-development-index/10192
Bennison, D. (1995), Retail planning policy in Greece, in R. Davies (ed.), Retailing Planning
Policies in Western Europe, Routledge: London.
Bitzenis, A., and Nito, E. (2005), Obstacles to entrepreneurship in a transition business
environment: the case of Albania, Journal of Small Business and Enterprise
Development, 12(4), 564-578.
Bocutoglu, E. and Atasoy, Y. (2001), Yükselen süpermarket olgusu karşısında bakkaliye
sektörünün yeri ve Trabzon örneği, Trabzon Esnaf ve Sanatkarlar Odaları Birliği Yayınları:
Trabzon, Turkey.
Calik (2009), Calik Holding grows in Europe with investments in Albania,
http://www.calik.com/en/PressReleases2009/2010/10/25/calik_holding_grows_in_europe_wi
th_investments_in_albania?id=7c9b25b2-c486-496c-993e-6404d4a9ef23, Access: October
2013.
Celen, A., Erdogan, T, Taymaz, E. (2005), Fast Moving Consumer Goods: Competitive
Conditions and Policies, ERC Working Papers in Economics, 05/03.
Cengiz, E., and Ozden, B. (2002), Perakendecilikte buyuk alısveris merkezleri ve
tüketicilerin büyük alısveris merkezleri ile ilgili tutumlarını tespit etmeye yönelik bir
araştırma, Ege Academic Review, 2(1), 64-77.
Chan-Halbrendt, C., Zhllimab, E., Sisiorc, G., Imamid, D., and Leonettie, L. (2010),
Consumer preferences for olive oil in Tirana, Albania, International Food and Agribusiness
Management Review, 13(3).
Coskun, R. (2001), Determinants of direct foreign investment in Turkey, European Business
Review, 13(4), 221-226.
Courser, Z. (2005), Wal-Mart and the politics of American retail, Competitive Enterprise
Institute Publication, 10.
Deloitte (2013), Global Powers of Retailing 2013, http://www.deloitte.com/assets/DcomAustralia/Local%20Assets/Documents/Industries/Consumer%20business/Deloitte_Global_Po
wers_of_Retail_2013.pdf, Access: October 2013.
Erdogan, T. (2003), Rekabet hukuku açısından perakende sektöründe alım gücü, Rekabet
Kurumu: Ankara, Turkey.
Erkip, F., Kızılgün, O., Mugan, G. (2013), The role of retailing in urban sustainability: the
Turkish case, European Urban and Regional Studies, 20(3), 329-342.
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
123
Kaleshi, E. and Solanki, M.K.S. (2010), A Mechanistic Framework for Foreign Direct
Investment in the case of Albania, Master Thesis Blekinge Institute of Technology, Sweden.
Kaynak, E. (1982), Marketing in the Third World, Praeger: New York.
Kaynak, E. (1986), Marketing and Economic Development, Praeger: New York.
Keskin, H., and Senturk, C. (2010), The importance of small and medium-sized enterprises
(SMEs) in economies: swot analyses of the SME sector in Turkey and Albania, Nigde
Universitesi İİBF Dergisi, 3(1), 116-132.
KobiEfor (2013), Türk yatırımcılarını baş tacı eden ülke: Arnavutluk, http://www.kobiefor.com.tr/ulke/pazarulke/turk-yatirimcilarini-bas-taci-eden-ulke-arnavutluk-h1550.html,
Access: October 2013.
Kose, A.H. and Oncu, A. (2000,) İşgücü piyasaları ve uluslararası isbolumunde
uzmanlasmanın mekansal boyutları: 1980 sonrası dönemde Turkiye imalat sanayii, Toplum
ve Bilim, 86, 72-90.
Kumcu, E. and Kumcu, M.E. (1987), Determinants of food retailing in developing
economies: the case of Turkey, Journal of Macromarketing, 26-40.
Kursunluoglu, E. (2006), Tüketicilerin süpermarket seçme tercihlerini etkileyen kriterlerin
belirlenmesine yönelik İzmir ilinde bir araştırma, Master Thesis Dokuz Eylul University,
Turkey.
Kursunluoglu, E. (2008), The criteria that influence consumers’ supermarket choices, IV.
International Conference on Business, Management and Economics, 2, 33-41.
Kursunluoglu, E. (2009), Mağazalı perakendeciler ve musteri servisleri, Journal of Yasar
University, 4(14), 2173-2184.
Lebhar, G.M. (2012), Chain Stores in America, 1859-1950, Hardpress Publishing: US.
Leonetti L, Viaggi, D., and Imami, D. (2009), Analysis of the dynamics of the wine market in
Albania, Newmedit.
Manrai, L. A., Manrai, A. K., and Lascu, D. N. (2001), A country-cluster analysis of the
distribution and promotion infrastructure in Central and Eastern Europe, International
Business Review, 10(5), 517-549.
Ministry of Economy (2012), Turkey-Albania Free Trade Agreement,
http://www.economy.gov.tr/index.cfm?sayfa=tradeagreements&bolum=fta&country=AL&re
gion=0, Access: October 2013.
Mucaj, G. (2013), Turkey is Albania’s strategic partner in Balkans - interviewed by Peter M.
Tase, http://www.eurasiareview.com/27042013-turkey-is-albanias-strategic-partner-inbalkans-interview-ambassador-mucaj/,
Access: October 2013.
Mukli, L., Cota, A., Mersini, R. (2012), Foreign direct investment and entry modes of mobile
telecommunication companies in Albania, European Scientific Journal, 8(7).
Myers, H. and Alexander, N. (1996), European food retailers’ evaluation of global markets,
International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, 24(6), 34-43.
Myers, H. (2003), European food retailers: paths for growth, European Retail Digest, 38.
OECD (1998), Competition law and policy in France,
http://www.oecd.org/france/34825657.pdf, Access: October 2013.
Orel, F.D. (2010), Uluslararası perakendecilik, Detay Yayıncılık: Ankara, Turkey.
Ozbilgic, Z. (2012), Foreign direct investment (FDI), Republic of Turkey Ministry of
Economy,http://www.ekonomi.gov.tr/upload/1F5D92A4-0380-4636-
2383FCAB5B8E39E5/zergul_ozbilgic.pdf, Access: November 2013.
Ozcan, G.B. (1997), Perakendecilikte evrenselleşme, Görüş (TUSIAD), 64.
Ozcan, G.B. (2000), The transformation of Turkish retailing: survival strategies of small and
medium-sized retailers, Journal of Southern Europe and the Balkans, 2(1).
Ozcan, G.B. (2001), Patterns of vertical and horizontal integration in Turkish retailing,
European Retail Digest, 32, 35-41.
European Scientific Journal February 2014 /SPECIAL/ edition vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431
124
Ozcan, G.B. (2007), Surviving through transplantation and cloning: the Swiss Migros hybrid,
Migros-Turk, Remaking Management ed. by Smith, C., McSweeney, B., and Fitzgerald, R.,
181-206.
Ozkan, B. and Akpinar, G. (2003), Gıda perakendeciliginde yeni bir acılım: market markali
gida urunleri, Pazarlama Dünyası, 17(1), 22.
Retail Turkiye (2013), Türkiye Toplam FMCG Ciro Trendi ve Büyüme Oranları (Kasım
2011 - Eylül 2013), http://www.retailturkiye.com/fmcg-ve-retail-pazari/turkiye-toplam-fmcgciro-trendi-ve-buyume-oranlari-kasim-2011-eylul-2013,
Access: November 2013.
Salgueiro, T.B. (1995), Retail planning policy in Portugal, in R. Davies (ed.), Retailing
Planning Policies in Western Europe, Routledge: London.
Samli, C. (1964), Wholesaling in an economy of scarcity: Turkey, Journal of Marketing, 28,
55-58.
Samli, C. (1970), Comparative analysis of marketing in Romania and Yugoslavia, Southern
Journal of Business, 5(2).
Savasci, İ. (2002), Tüketicinin perakendeci marka tercihleri: Izmir hipermarketleri
kapsamında bir arastırma, Master Thesis Ege University, Turkey.
Tahiroglu, F. (1999), Musteri odaklı kaliteli servis ekipleri, Human Resources, 8.
Tek, O.B. and Ozgul, E. (2005), Modern pazarlama ilkeleri, Birleşik Matbaacılık: İzmir,
Turkey.
Tek, O.B. (2008), Turkiye’de perakendecilik cagı ve buyuk olcekli perakendeci
magazalarıngelişimi,http://www.rekabet.gov.tr/File/?path=ROOT%2FDocuments%2FPer%2
5c5%259fembe%2BKonferans%25c4%25b1%2BYay%25c4%25b1n%2Fperskonfyyn24.pdf,
Access: November 2013.
Tokatli, N. and Boyaci, Y. (1998), The changing retail industry and retail landscapes: the
case of post-1980 Turkey, Cities, 15(5), 345-359.
Torlak, O., Uzkurt, C., and Ozmen, M. (2010), Dimensions of service quality in grocery
retailing: a case from Turkey, Management Research Review, 33(5), 413-422.
Turkey Grocery Stores and Dealers Federation (2000), Hiper-grosmarketler karşısında bakkal
ve market esnafının durumu, http://www.tbbf.org.tr/tr/guncel/rapor.html, September 2013.
Varinli, I. and Oyman, M. (2013), Perakendecilige giris, ed. by Ozturk, S.A., Anadolu
Universitesi Yayınları: Eskisehir, Turkey.
Wood, S., Lowe, M., Wrigley, N. (2006), Life after PPG6—recent UK food retailer responses
to planning regulation tightening, International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer
Research, 16(1), 23-41.
Yeldan, A. E. (2001), On the Imf-directed disinflation program in Turkey: a program for
stabilization and usterity or a recipe for impoverishment and financial chaos?. Available at
SSRN 290539.
Yilmaz, M. and Altunisik, R. (2003), Perakende sektorunde kurulus yeri seciminde cografi
bilgi sisteminin kullanılması, 8. Ulusal Pazarlama Kongresi, Erciyes Universitesi.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission
Aktivitas
Primer : 
